I wrote about AI and its writing prowess over a year ago in this column. Many of those of you who commented then felt that ChatGPT’s writing was soulless and repetitive and unlikely to usurp that of us humans.

I thought it would be interesting to share an update and see if your feelings have changed.

I asked ChatGPT to write me a ten paragraph book review of Lisa Kleypas’ classic Devil in Winter. Here’s what it produced:

Lisa Kleypas’ “Devil in Winter,” the third installment in her Wallflowers series, offers a refreshing take on the Regency romance genre. The novel follows the unconventional union of Evangeline Jenner, a stammering wallflower, and Sebastian, Lord St. Vincent, a notorious rake. Kleypas’ nuanced character development and richly detailed historical setting make this a standout in the crowded field of historical romance.

Evangeline, or Evie, is not your typical romantic heroine. Desperate to escape her abusive relatives, she boldly proposes a marriage of convenience to Sebastian. This unexpected move sets the stage for a story that is as much about personal growth as it is about romance. Kleypas handles Evie’s transformation from a timid girl to a confident woman with great sensitivity, ensuring that her evolution feels both realistic and compelling.

Sebastian begins the novel as a charming yet jaded aristocrat, more interested in pleasure than in commitment. However, as the story progresses, Kleypas peels back the layers of his character, revealing a man capable of deep affection and loyalty. This gradual revelation is handled with a deft touch, making his journey from rake to devoted husband believable and satisfying.

The chemistry between Evie and Sebastian is expertly crafted. Kleypas excels at creating tension and intimacy between her protagonists, making their developing relationship feel authentic. Their interactions are marked by witty exchanges and genuine emotional connection, ensuring that the romance is engaging without being overly saccharine.

The historical setting of “Devil in Winter” is another of the novel’s strengths. Kleypas paints a vivid picture of Regency England, from its grand ballrooms to its seedy gambling halls. This rich backdrop not only enhances the story’s authenticity but also immerses the reader in the period, providing a compelling context for the romance.

Secondary characters play a significant role in the novel, adding depth and complexity to the narrative. The loyal Wallflowers—Evie’s close friends—offer support and camaraderie, while figures like Ivo Jenner, Evie’s father, bring an element of danger and intrigue. These well-drawn characters enrich the story, creating a fuller and more immersive world.

Themes of redemption and personal growth are central to “Devil in Winter.” Both Evie and Sebastian must confront their pasts and insecurities to forge a future together. Kleypas explores these themes thoughtfully, adding a layer of depth to the romance that makes the characters’ journeys feel meaningful and rewarding.

Kleypas’ prose is both elegant and accessible, striking a balance between vivid description and engaging dialogue. Her writing flows smoothly, making “Devil in Winter” a compelling read from start to finish. The narrative is well-paced, with a mix of action, dialogue, and introspection that keeps the reader engaged.

The emotional depth of the novel is one of its standout features. Kleypas does not shy away from exploring the darker aspects of her characters’ lives, which adds a sense of gravitas to the story. This depth makes the characters’ eventual happiness all the more poignant and satisfying.

“Devil in Winter” is a prime example of how historical romance can be both entertaining and substantive. Lisa Kleypas has crafted a novel that not only delivers a satisfying love story but also explores themes of resilience and transformation. Fans of the genre will find much to admire in this well-crafted tale.

In a genre often criticized for formulaic plots and flat characters, “Devil in Winter” stands out for its rich character development and historical detail. Lisa Kleypas has proven once again that she is a master of her craft, delivering a novel that is as emotionally resonant as it is enjoyable. This book is a must-read for anyone seeking a romance that goes beyond the ordinary.

Is it as good as Lea’s review? No. Absolutely not. But, if I hadn’t told you, would you have thought it was by a bot? I’m not so sure.

What do you think? Have your feelings about AI changed since last January?